skip to main content
Nov 2026

From Caregiver to Beneficiary: The $30-million affair in the Waters Estate

Waters Estate v. Henry 2026 ONCA 704

By Apeksha Jain

The Ontario Court of Appeal recently heard the case of Waters Estate v. Henry, where one of the main issues was over $30 million transferred by William Waters (“William”) to Gillian Henry (“Ms. Henry”) over a period of ten years. Ms. Henry, who was struggling financially at the time, got hired to care for William’s housebound wife, Phyllis, and subsequently found herself living the good life until the estate battle began.  

The (thirty) million-dollar question: was it a gift or resulting trust?

The appeal comes from the 2024 trial decision of Justice Callaghan, where, among other things, he had emphasized the testator’s autonomy and found that “the equitable principle of resulting trust is not intended to oust a person’s autonomy; rather, it is intended to ensure that the money was truly gifted. In this case, over 10 years, William gave a substantial portion of his estate to an intimate partner.” - The Estate of William Robert Waters v Gillian Henry et al, 2024 ONSC 4190 (CanLII) - at para 318. 

The Court of Appeal found that errors in the trial judge’s assessment—including how he approached the burden of proof, admissibility of William’ handwritten notes and evidence of the couple’s relationship—required the key issues to be reconsidered, and ordered a new trial. 

Facts:

William was a wealthy businessman, academic and philanthropist. In 2009, Ms. Henry began working as a personal support worker for William’s wife, Phyllis. Ms. Henry, a separated single mother, was offered a $60,000 salary to care for Phyllis, which was the most income she had ever made. Over the next ten years, Ms. Henry went on to purchase and renovate properties, develop a horse-riding farm and stable business known as King of Hearts, pay off debts for family members, buy luxury vehicles and jewellery, living a lavish lifestyle. 

How? William transferred more than $30 million to Ms. Henry in at least 393 transactions from his own assets as well as his wife’s.

Unsurprisingly, after William died, his estate argued that many of the transfers were investments or funds William continued to own beneficially. Ms. Henry’s position was that these were gifts from a man with whom she had a long-term intimate relationship, which they kept a secret from everyone else. 

At trial, Justice Callaghan accepted that the relationship was intimate and long-standing. He found that Ms. Henry had rebutted the presumption of a resulting trust for most of the transfers, except for the business, King of Hearts Stables (“King of Hearts”), in which he found William retained an 80% beneficial interest, and certain amounts that Mr. William transferred from his wife Phyllis’ funds, were owed back to Phyllis and the Estate.

The Estate appealed and Ms. Henry cross appealed arguing that the trial judge erred in finding that William retained a beneficial interest in King of Hearts, and in awarding money to Phyllis when she was not a party to the action.

The Court of Appeal allowed the Estate’s appeal and ordered a new trial.

Presumption of Resulting Trust 

When property is transferred without payment or other consideration, the law generally presumes that the recipient holds it in trust for the transferor. This is well established in the case of Pecore v. Pecore, 2007 SCC 17. The recipient must rebut that presumption by proving, on a balance of probabilities, that the transferor intended to make a gift.

The Court of Appeal found that although the trial judge stated the legal rule correctly, he did not apply it properly. Rather than asking whether Ms. Henry had shown that William intended to give up his interest in the money, the judge looked for evidence that William intended to keep an interest. In effect, this reversed the burden of proof by placing it on the Estate.

The Court of Appeal also found that the transfers could not all be treated as though they had the same purpose. A finding that some payments were gifts did not establish that the numerous other transfers—made at different times and for different reasons—were gifts too. The transactions wouldn’t need to be examined separately, but a judge must distinguish meaningfully between different types of transfers.

Admissibility of William’ Handwritten Notes 

The Estate had introduced William’s handwritten notes about the monies he gave Ms. Henry as evidence. The trial judge excluded most of William’s handwritten financial notes as hearsay but admitted a note concerning King of Hearts. The estate argued that the notes could help show how William viewed and tracked the money.

The Court of Appeal set aside the trial judge’s treatment of the notes. It did not rule that all the notes are admissible or that they prove the Estate’s case; rather their admissibility and weight must be reconsidered at the new trial.

The Court of Appeal also noted an apparent inconsistency: the trial judge excluded some notes as unreliable while relying on the King of Hearts note, which contained similar inaccuracies.

The Affair and the Law of Evidence Requiring Corroboration  

The Court accepted that the relationship could be relevant to whether William intended to make gifts. But it found that the trial judge gave the relationship too much weight, treating it both as evidence of donative intent and as corroboration of Ms. Henry’s account.

Further, Section 13 of Ontario’s Evidence Act requires independent, material evidence to corroborate an interested person’s evidence about events before a deceased person’s death in an action involving an estate. A person’s evidence cannot corroborate itself. It was mostly Ms. Henry’s evidence that the two had an intimate relationship, along with a doctor’s note in a medical file indicating that William saw a urologist, apparently wishing to correct his erectile dysfunction. The Court said while the relationship could provide context, it was not on its own, the required corroboration of the transfers.

The Decision: 

The Court of Appeal allowed the Estate’s appeal and dismissed Ms. Henry’s cross-appeal. It:

  • Ordered a new trial on the disputed transfers and related issues, including the estate’s limitation-period and fiduciary-duty claims;
  • Upheld the finding that William retained an 80% beneficial interest in King of Hearts;
  • Upheld the order requiring Ms. Henry to repay $970,000 in outstanding loans; and
  • Upheld the recovery of $1,938,000 in Phyllis’s funds, with the estate required to pay that amount promptly to her;

The appeal court’s decision does not resolve whether the disputed transfers were gifts or held in trust. The outcome will depend on a fresh assessment of the evidence at a new trial, including the purpose of the transfers and William’s records.

For now, the decision is a reminder that in disputes over a deceased person’s assets, the question is not simply whether the giver was generous, but whether the recipient can establish that each disputed transfer was, in fact, intended as a gift. Intention, as always, is key!

For questions about gifts and resulting trusts, please contact Apeksha Jain at ajain@sorbaralaw.com.