skip to main content
Nov 2026

Non-Compete vs. Non-Solicitation Agreements in Ontario: Why Careful Drafting Matters

By Delzad Kutky

Non-compete and non-solicitation covenants are important tools for protecting business interests in mergers and acquisitions (M&A), business sales, and franchise relationships. For business owners, buyers, sellers, franchisors, and franchisees these restrictions can help protect goodwill, customer relationships, confidential information, and business value.

However, restrictive covenants are not automatically enforceable in Ontario. When these provisions go before courts, they are carefully scrutinized and poorly drafted clauses may be found unenforceable altogether.

What are Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Covenants?

A non-compete covenant restricts a party from certain activities for a specific period of time and within a defined geographic area. The restricted activities will depend on what was contractually agreed upon, but often include carrying on, operating, owning, or participating in a competing business. In an M&A transaction, for example, a purchaser may require the seller to agree not to operate a competing business or buy into a competing business as a major investor following closing. This helps protect the goodwill and customer relationships acquired as part of the transaction.

In a franchise context, a non-compete covenant may restrict a franchisee from operating a competing business during the franchise relationship and often for a period of time after its termination or expiry.

A non-solicitation covenant is generally narrower than its non-compete counterpart. Rather than prohibiting competition altogether, it can restrict a party from actively soliciting certain customers, clients, suppliers, employees, or other business relationships.

For example, following the sale of a business, a non-compete covenant may prohibit the seller from establishing a competing business within 10 kilometres of their original company for a year. If the seller creates a new competing business 11 kilometres down the road, the buyer may still suffer. A well-drafted non-solicitation covenant could prevent the seller from approaching clients of the original business to divert them to their new company. Similarly, a franchise agreement may restrict a former franchisee from soliciting customers of the franchise network or recruiting employees from other franchise locations.

Why Can Restrictive Covenants Be Unenforceable in Ontario?

Ontario courts scrutinize restrictive covenants to determine whether they are reasonable and necessary to protect legitimate business interests as non-compete and non-solicitation clauses can unduly restrict trade.

Common drafting issues include:

  • Overly broad restrictions: Prohibiting competition or solicitation beyond what is reasonably necessary.
  • Unreasonable time periods: Imposing restrictions that extend longer than necessary to protect goodwill or other legitimate interests.
  • Excessive geographic scope: Restricting business activities in areas where the business has no meaningful commercial presence.
  • Ambiguous language: Failing to clearly define what constitutes competition or solicitation.
  • Overreaching definitions: Restricting relationships with customers, suppliers, or business contacts with whom the restricted party had no meaningful connection.

Importantly, Ontario courts will not necessarily rewrite an unreasonable restrictive covenant to make it enforceable. A poorly drafted provision may be declared unenforceable altogether. What does that mean for the overreaching buyer trying to protect their investment? Their insistence on asking for a city-wide prohibition on competition instead of a smaller geographic radius, or a 3-year restriction instead of 18 months, may result in no protection at all.

When Should You Have a Restrictive Covenant Reviewed?

Many business owners recognize the importance of obtaining legal advice before signing an agreement containing non-compete or non-solicitation covenants. However, legal advice can also be valuable long after an agreement has been signed. When a former business partner starts a competing business or starts reaching out to your clients or suppliers, we can review the restrictive covenants in your agreements and help you determine the best path forward to meet your commercial goals.

Similarly, if you have recently purchased a business and believe the former owner is competing in breach of their contractual obligations, obtaining legal advice promptly can help you understand your rights and available options.

On the other hand, if you have sold a company or left a business project, legal advice can be invaluable to helping you understand what restrictions or speedbumps you may be facing on your new business ventures.

The Importance of Careful Drafting and Our Expertise

Whether negotiating the purchase or sale of a business, preparing a franchise agreement, or bringing in investors to a project, restrictive covenants should be tailored to the specific transaction and commercial relationship. A properly drafted covenant should clearly define the restricted activities, and ensure that its duration, geographic scope, and overall restrictions are no broader than reasonably necessary.

A one-size-fits-all approach can create significant enforcement risks. The appropriate restrictions in an M&A transaction may differ considerably from those required in a franchise agreement, or a shareholder agreement. Furthermore, restrictive covenants can have significant financial and commercial consequences, particularly if that clause becomes central to a dispute before Ontario’s courts.

Whether you are buying or selling a business, negotiating a commercial agreement, or protecting an established franchise network, obtaining legal advice on the drafting and enforceability of these provisions is essential. From our Markham offices, our team assists purchasers, sellers, franchisors, and franchisees throughout the Greater Toronto Area with M&A transactions, franchise agreements, and commercial contracts.